Bethel Mar Thoma Church started as a chapel of the Chicago Mar Thoma Church in 1991. The chapel met in a rented hall belonging to the Nazarene Church of Tinley Park. On September 1, 1994, the chapel bought its own church building. His Grace the Rt. Rev. Dr. Zacharias Mar Theophilus, the diocesan bishop, dedicated the building on November 13, 1994. The chapel was elevated to the status of an independent church under the name Bethel Mar Thoma Church on January 1, 1995.

The following achens have served as vicars:

  1. Rev. Renji Varghese -- 1st vicar of the chapel
  2. Rev. George Mathew -- During achen's time the current church building was purchased
  3. Rev. Jaims Thomas -- The 1st vicar of Bethel Mar Thoma Church
  4. Rev. Dr. P.P. Thomas
  5. Rev. Dr. George Samuel
  6. Rev. V.T. John
  7. Rev. Philip Varghese
  8. Rev. Varghese Mathew
  9. Rev. Sabu Thomas -- interim vicar
  10. Rev. Alex Peter
  11. Rev. George Cherian
  12. Rev. Christopher Phil Daniel
  13. Rev. Thomas Mathew -- interim vicar
  14. Rev. Joymon S.K.